Contemporary Political Studies

Contemporary Political Studies

Analysis of Gender Justice Discourse in Parties and Non-Governmental Organizations (NGOs) (Case Study of 1991s-2001s)

Document Type : .

Authors
1 phd student .Department of Political Science. Karaj Branch .Islamic Azad University. Karaj. Iran
2 Assistant Professor, Department of Political Science, Karaj Branch, Islamic Azad University, Karaj, Iran.
Abstract
Abstract
Efforts to explain the concept of "gender justice" as an alternative to gender equality in our country is commendable if it is the beginning of the elimination of discriminations. Widespread participation of women in parties and non-governmental organizations plays an effective role in political and social development and power distribution system; and it leads to the reform of the political and social structure of the country by preventing the monopoly of power.
In the present study, issue of gender justice and problems of women activists in two decades of 1991 and 2001 and the extent of their participation and mode of action in parties and NGOs have been stated; and this basic question has been answered that whether parties and NGOs suffer from gender discriminations within their structure. Qualitative and descriptive methods were used to find the answer. The results of documentary studies, coding and categorization of interviews data through MAXQDA software and using the content analysis method and Grounded theory showed that although NGOs had been in much better situation for presenting and playing the participatory role of women, but existence of gender justice within the country's civil institutions, especially political parties, is still far from the desired level.
Keywords: gender justice, gender discrimination, women participation, parties, non-governmental organizations (NGOs).
 
Introduction
There are many narratives about equality in rights and justice in the participation of men and women. Equality, like justice, is one of the fundamental values of human societies. However, when we get into the details, there is not much agreement about the meaning of justice or equality, and where there is some agreements, we will find only an illusionary appearance that only seeks to resolve difference of opinions.  As even among women, we face biased readings of equality in favor of men. With its long history, our country has seen huge changes in the presence of women in society. But what we are looking for in this research is to investigate the facts and sayings of the observance or non-observance of gender justice in parties and NGOs in the two decades of 1370 and 1380.
 
Materials & methods
The political and civil demands of Iranian women show that they are looking for an Iranian and national-Islamic narrative of feminism. Since we consider Islam as a dynamic and inclusive religion, then there is a capacity in its religious texts to retake the lost rights of women by reading it correctly. Also, study of the level of political and social participation of women in political parties and non-governmental organizations, which is directly related to the issue of hierarchical marginalization of women in political and social issues, is one of the issues raised in feminist movements.
To find the answer to the main research question, qualitative and descriptive methods were used. The results of documentary studies, coding and categorization of interview data and using the method of content analysis and Grounded Theory showed that NGOs have been in a better position for the presence and role of women's participation, but the existence of gender justice within the country's civil institutions, especially political parties, is still far from the desired level.
 
Discussion
The defense of women's rights is not limited to certain geographical boundaries. Researchers and supporters of feminist theories and attitudes have made great efforts in different eras in order to destroy the dominance of men and provide practical solutions. Despite the fact that these activities continued and citizenship rights equal to men were approved in most European countries, women still have a more difficult situation in accessing their rights compared to men. So there is a gap between theory and practice. The existing gap is the cause of a basic and fundamental question, why is there still no social justice? Since political parties are the guardians of democracy in many European countries, the fair participation of women in these institutions leads to the presence of women in legislative assemblies and decision-making centers, and as a result, it leads to the design of political and electoral systems that Institutionalization and transparency are promoted in them.
Sazandegi Era, with the efforts of its political actors, led to fundamental changes in the political and economic structure of the country and the emergence of a new class of demanding women and young people. The new class, which included young people and educated women, sought to form new civil institutions such as parties and NGOs in order to increase their participation in political, economic, cultural issues, etc. Therefore, Sazandegi Era can be considered as the starting point of the formation of all kinds of organizations of its modern type. Basically, the 70s and 80s are studied in this research due to the increase of women's willingness to participate in society through civil institutions such as parties and NGOs.
 
Conclusion
The pattern resulting from the research data through coding techniques in content analysis and after identifying and categorizing different categories shows that all the interviewees emphasize the existence of gender discrimination in both political parties and non-governmental organizations. Also, in explaining the results of the research, we divided the reasons for the existence of gender justice in parties and NGOs into two categories: external factors and internal factors. The increase in repetition of the codes obtained from the text of the opinions of the interviewees and the relationship between the main statement, i.e. the existence of discrimination in these two civil institutions, indicates the abundance of research data in favor of the existence of wider discrimination in parties.
 
Keywords

The Holy Quran
قرآن
Persian
Abbaszadeh, Saeedeh (2015) "A Comparative Study of Five Development Plans of the Country, on Achieving Gender Justice with Emphasis on the Status of Women's Higher Education in Iran and Its Comparison with the State of the World", Women's Research Journal, Spring 6, No. 1
عباسزاده، سعیده (1394) «بررسی تطبیقی پنج برنامه توسعه کشور، پیرامون دستیابی به عدالت جنسیتی با تاکید بر وضعیت آموزش عالی زنان در ایران و مقایسه آن با وضعیت جهان»، پژوهشنامه زنان، سال ششم بهار  شماره1
Ahmadvand, Wali Mohammad; Khorasani, Reza; (2017) "Feasibility Study of the Party in the Islamic Republic of Iran", Transcendent politics , summer - No. 17, pp. 137 to 154
احمدوند، ولی‏محمد؛ خراسانی، رضا؛( 1396) «امکانسنجی تحزب در جمهوری اسلامی ایران»،  سیاست متعالیه تابستان، شماره 17 ،صص 137- 154
Alizad, Esmaeil, (2004-2005) A Study of the Role of Mass Media in Political Participation, Master Thesis, Faculty of Social Sciences, Allameh Tabatabaei University,
عالی زاد، اسماعیل،( 1384-1383) «بررسی نقش وسایل ارتباط جمعی در مشارکت سیاسی»، پایان‏نامه کارشناسی ارشد دانشکده علوم اجتماعی دانشگاه علامه طباطبایی،
Cheraghi Koutiani, Ismail, (2014) "Iranians' Confrontation with Iranian Feminism to Islamic Feminism", Marefat, No. 199, pp. 31 to 48
چراغی کوتیانی، اسماعیل،(1393) «رویارویی ایرانیان با فمینیسم ایرانی تا فمینیسم اسلامی»، معرفت، شماره 199، صص 31 - 48
Farastkhah, Maghsoud, 2022, Research Methods in Social Sciences (with Emphasis on Based Theory) GTM Grounded Theory, Tehran, Agah,
فراست‏خواه، مقصود، 1400، روش تحقیق در علوم اجتماعی (با تاکید بر نظریه برپایه) گرانددتئوری GTM ، تهران، آگاه، ،
Friedman, Jane, (2002), Feminism, (Firoozeh Mohajer), Second Edition, Tehran: Ashian.
فریدمن، جین، (1381)، فمینیسم، فیروزه مهاجر، چاپ دوم، تهران: آشیان
Hosseinzadeh, Abolhossein;Abbasian, Hossein (2015) "Critique of the Intellectual Principles and Characteristics of Islamic Feminism", Religious Anthropology, Autumn and Winter, No. 34, pp. 207-222
حسین‏زاده، ابوالحسین، عباسیان، حسین(1394) «نقد و بررسی مبانی فکری و شاخصه های فمینیسم اسلامی»، انسان پژوهی دینی، پاییز و زمستان ، شماره 34،صص 207 - 228
Kadivar, Jamileh, (1997), Woman, first edition, Tehran: Information.
کدیور، جمیله، (1375)، زن، چاپ اول، تهران‌: اطلاعات‌.
Khalili, Mohsen (2007) "Pathology of Women's Participation in Contemporary Iranian Society", Women's Research, Volume 5, Number 2, P.3
خلیلی، محسن(1386) «آسیب شناسی مشارکت زنان در جامعه معاصر ایران»، پژوهش زنان، دوره 5 ، شماره2،ص 3
Masoudnia, Hussein; Nazari, Mina; Mohammadifar, Nejat (2014) "A Comparative Study of the Presence of Women in the Legislature: Developments Before and After the Islamic Revolution of Iran" Woman in Development and Politics, Volume 11, Number 4, Winter, pp. 575-594
مسعودنیا، حسین؛ نظری، مینا ؛ محمدی‏فر، نجات (1392)«مطالعة تطبیقی حضور زن در قوة مقننه: تحولات قبل و بعد از انقلاب اسلامی ایران»، زن در توسعه و سیاست، دوره 11، شماره 4، زمستان ، صص 575-594
Michelle, Andre, (2004) Women's Movement, Zanjanizadeh, Homa, Mashhad, Nika Publishing
میشل، آندره، (1383) جنبش زنان، زنجانی‏زاده، هما، مشهد، نشر نیکا
Mirkhani, Ezat al-Sadat, Shakeri Golpayegani, Toobi, Badreh, Mohsen (2015), "Methodological evolution in the so-called" Islamic feminism ", gender and family studies" Autumn and Winter - No. 3, pp. 169-204
میرخانی، عزت السادات، شاکری گلپایگانی، طوبی، بدره، محسن(1393)،«تطور روش‌شناختی در جریان موسوم به «فمینیسم اسلامی» مطالعات جنسیّت و خانواده، شماره 3،صص  169 تا 204
Mirkhani, Ezzat Sadat (2014); "Analysis of gender justice in emotional, moral and Family Economic Relations », Woman in Culture and Art, Spring, Volume 5 - Number 1, pp. 103 to 124
میرخانی، عزت-السادات(1392) ؛ «تحلیل عدالت جنسیتی در مناسبات عاطفی، اخلاقی و روابط اقتصادی خانواده»، زن در فرهنگ و هنر، بهار، دوره پنجم، شماره 1 ،صص 103-124
Mohseni, Reza Ali; Khoshfar, Gholamreza; Babaei, Ghorban Ali; Ebrahimi, Mitra (2014) "Study of Factors Affecting the Motivation of Women's Participation in Non-Governmental Organizations" Journal of Women and Society, Summer, Fourth Year - No. 2 ,pp 167 to 190
محسنی، رضا علی؛خوشفر، غلامرضا؛ بابایی، قربان علی؛ ابراهیمی، میترا(1392)« بررسی عامل‏های موثر بر انگیزه مشارکت زنان در سازمان‏های مردم‏نهاد»، زن و جامعه، تابستان، سال چهارم، شماره، صص 167 تا 190
Nozari, Hossein Ali (2002) Political Parties and Party Systems, Tehran: Gostareh.
نوذری، حسینعلی(1381) احزاب سیاسی و نظام‏های حزبی، تهران: گستره.
Qaderzadeh, Omid; Rezazadeh, Fatemeh (2020) "Study of life experience and women's perception of activity and participation in civic institutions" Sociology of social institutions in autumn and winter - No. 14 (pp 63 to 96)
قادر‏زاده، امید؛رضازاده، فاطمه (1398)«مطالعه‌ی تجربه‌ی ‌زیسته و درک زنان از فعالیت و مشارکت در نهادهای مدنی»، جامعه شناسی نهاد‏های اجتماعی، پاییز و زمستان، شماره 14، صص63 - 96
Qasempour, Fatemeh,Nosrat Kharazmi, Zohreh; Nosrat Kharazmi, Hananeh (2021) "Cultural Action of Women after the Islamic Revolution: A Discourse Analysis of the Claims of Islamic Feminism in the Islamic Republic of Iran" Social Studies and Research in Iran, Winter, Volume 9 – Number 4, pp 937 to 966
قاسمپور، فاطمه، نصرت خوارزمی، زهره؛ نصرت خوارزمی، حنانه( 1399)«کنش فرهنگی زنان پس ‌از انقلاب اسلامی: تحلیل گفتمان مطالبات فمینیسم اسلامی در جمهوری اسلامی ایران»، مطالعات و تحقیقات اجتماعی در ایران، زمستان، دوره نهم - شماره 4 ،صص 937 - 966
Shafiee Sarvestani, Ebrahim, (2000) Currents of Defending Women's Rights in Iran, Qom, Taha Cultural Institute
شفیعی سروستانی، ابراهیم،( 1379)، جریان‏های دفاع از حقوق زنان در ایران، قم، موسسه فرهنگی طه
Shahidian, Hamed (1998) "Islamic Feminism and the Iranian Women's Movement", Irannameh. Autumn, No. 64, pp. 611-640
شهیدیان، حامد(1377)، «فمینیسم اسلامی و جنبش زنان ایران»، ایران‏نامه، پاییز، شماره64، صص 611 - 640
Zahed, Zeidollah; Nasrollahi, Zahra; Mahinizadeh, Mansour (2021) From Gender Discrimination to Equality and Economic Growth (Study of Developing Countries) Women in Development and Politics, No. 70 , pp. 643 to 662, Winter
زاهد، زیدالله، نصرالهی، زهرا، مهینی‏زاده، منصور( 1399) «از تبعیض جنسیتی به سوی برابری و رشد اقتصادی ( مطالعه کشورهای در حال توسعه)» زن در توسعه و سیاست، شماره70 ،صص 643 - 662 ،
 
English
Badran, Morgot 2002. Islamic Feminism: What ‘s In a Name ?, AlAhram Weekly online 569. January, in http://www.weekly.ahram.org
Barlas, Asma, (2002) Believing women in Islam, unreading Partrirchal i \ Interpretions of the Quran, University of texas press, Austin, united States of America,.
https://moi.ir News portal of the Ministry of Interior Last visit October 2, 2021
OSCE;) 2014 (, Handbook 0n promoting Women’s Participation in Political Parties, OSCE Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights.