Contemporary Political Studies

Contemporary Political Studies

Health inequality of vulnerable groups of society and the effect of government policies on its reduction

Document Type : .

Authors
1 Department of Political Science, Kish International Branch, Islamic Azad University, Kish Island, Iran
2 Department of Political Science, Kish International Branch, Islamic Azad University, Kish Island, Iran Professor of political science and international relations at Gilan University
3 Department of Political Science, Kish International Branch, Islamic Azad University, Kish Island, Iran Professor of International Relations, Khwarazmi University
Abstract
Abstract
This article examines health inequality among vulnerable groups in society and the policies adopted by the government to reduce this inequality. The research aims to answer the question of how universal health coverage policies have influenced the allocation of resources, particularly to vulnerable groups such as women, children, and marginalized populations, in terms of implementing health equity policies. The hypothesis of this study is based on the premise that sociological and political factors in the allocation of resources for health transformation in Iran are primarily influenced by existing inequalities in healthcare and the demand for social justice in this area. Findings indicate that attention to vulnerable groups has consistently been a priority in the macro health policies of the Islamic Republic from the beginning, leading decision-makers to allocate resources to address these inequalities and focus on these vulnerable populations. The research concludes that despite some reductions in inequalities, the health sector still requires the establishment and expansion of key elements for implementing social justice, including universal health insurance, shifting from employer-based to government-based insurance coverage, remote healthcare, such as telemedicine and digital health, and a paradigm shift from the volume of healthcare services to the value of healthcare services. This article employs a qualitative, descriptive-analytical method, with data collected through literature reviews and document analysis.
Keywords: Social Justice, Equality, Human Rights, Government-Based Insurance, Digital Health.
 
Introduction
In recent years, achieving equality and addressing existing inequalities in the health system, especially among vulnerable groups, has become a significant concern for policymakers and health experts. The government has implemented various policies and initiatives to address these issues within the framework of the Health System Transformation Plan. However, it is important to recognize that health and its inequalities are closely linked to various social, economic, and political factors, including income level, education, occupation, and access to healthcare services. This study aims to analyze the impact of health inequalities on vulnerable groups, including women, children, and marginalized populations, by examining macro-level policies aimed at addressing these issues and assessing their effectiveness in reducing health inequalities and promoting social justice in health. The central question is: What role does universal health coverage play in shaping the allocation of healthcare resources in Iran, particularly concerning vulnerable groups such as women, children, and residents of impoverished areas? The hypothesis of this article is based on recognizing the right to health for all individuals in society. Accordingly, the government has an obligation to ensure this right comprehensively. The government's responsibility should be directed towards achieving social justice, particularly health equity. This article reviews government policies regarding vulnerable groups, identifies existing challenges, and examines the necessity of implementing new policies.
 
Materials and methods
The research method in this article is qualitative-descriptive, focusing on analyzing inequalities among vulnerable groups in society through a review of literature, studies, and published reports to examine the impact of government policies on addressing inequalities in health based on available data.
 
Discussions and Results
The analysis of health inequalities among vulnerable populations in Iran reveals significant differences among various social and demographic factors, such as gender, age, socioeconomic status, and geographical location. These inequalities highlight the need for targeted government policies to address the unique healthcare needs of these groups and ensure equitable access to quality healthcare services. This article examines three groups based on age, gender, and social status: infants, children, adolescents, and the elderly as the first group; women as the second group; and populations residing in impoverished and marginalized areas as the third group. Statistics and recent research confirm that these vulnerable groups still face challenges, such as limited resources, discrimination, and a lack of well-planned and principled policymaking. Nevertheless, the examination of macro-level policies since the revolution underscores that the status of these groups, particularly the implementation of social justice for them, has been a key focus and concern. It has also contributed to improving their situation and advancing justice to some extent. The findings suggest that reducing health inequalities in Iran, alongside other government initiatives, has achieved successes, particularly through a focus on universal health coverage and improving healthcare infrastructure in impoverished areas. However, further efforts are needed to achieve health equity in Iran, emphasizing the prioritization of the needs of vulnerable populations.
 
Conclusion
The research confirms that the government of the Islamic Republic of Iran has taken significant steps to ensure equal opportunities for all citizens to access optimal health and well-being. However, the existence of inequalities in the health system necessitates the establishment of additional key elements, which are categorized into three areas in this article: universal health insurance and the transition from employer-based insurance to government-based coverage; remote healthcare, including telemedicine and digital health; and the paradigm shift from the volume of healthcare services to the value of healthcare services.
Keywords

Subjects


Abedini, Arash. (2014). Examining the concept of social justice. Tehran, Iran: Islamic Council Research Center. 1-65 https://sid.ir/paper/802192/fa. [in Persian]
Bac Dorin, Paul (2008), "A history of the Concept of Sustainable Development: Literature Review", Annals of University of Oradeo, Economic Science Series, Vol. 17. Issue 2, PP. 581-585. 
Baloch Rafsanjani, Goddess; Maruti Sharif Abad, Mohammad Ali, Jam Bersang, Sara; Mirzaei, Mohsen. (1401). "Health needs of the elderly in Rafsanjan, Iran". Salamand: Iranian Journal of Geriatrics. Volume 17. Number 2. 232-245. [in Persian]
Baoush, Masoumeh; Shiani, Maliha; Musaei, Maitham. (2016). "Analysis of socio-economic factors affecting poverty and inequality in the field of health during the years 2015-2016". Social Welfare Quarterly. 17th year Number 67. Winter. 71-108. [in Persian]
Behbahani brothers, Ali; Bahrami, Fahima. (2019) "Poverty and inequality in the health sector". The collection of reports on poverty, inequality and conflict of interests of the Office of Social Welfare Studies of the Ministry of Cooperation, Labor and Social Welfare. No. 76. 1-142. [in Persian]
Constitution of the World Health, Organization. Geneva, 1946. Available online at: http://www.who.int /governance/eb/
Faraji Arpanahi, Zahra; Ebrahimifar, Jalal; Abdulahi Arpanahi, Masoumeh; Ebrahimifar, Isa; Abdulahi Arpanahi, Zainab. (2019). "Realization of the approach of social justice from the perspective of the Holy Quran and hadiths". Human Islamic Sciences, sixth year. Number 22. Summer. 19-26. [in Persian]
Ghaninejad, Musa. (2010). "Justice, social justice and economy". Reflection of thought. Number 15. 9-22. [in Persian]
Golestani, Sadiq. (2016). "The place of social justice in Islam". The coaches. sixth year No. 21. 6-40. [in Persian]
Haqpanah, Reza. (2008). "Social justice in the Qur'an". Islamic social studies (former field of thought). Number 30. [in Persian]
Harvard University Press. Revised edition. http://www.who.int/governance /eb/
Ironworkers, Nestern; Pourjamshidi, Zahra. (2021). "Category of cause of death in young people according to ICD10". Behorz Quarterly. Year 32. Number 108. 66-71. [in Persian]
Jafari Niya, Abbas. (2018). "Social justice, spatial justice and development". Geography quarterly (regional planning) 10th year. Number 1. Summer. 298-311. [in Persian]
Jamshidi Mehr, Fardin; Masoudi, Jahangir; Kohensal, Alireza. (2016). "Analysis of the nature of justice in the field of ethics with an emphasis on Ibn Sina's views". Hekmat Sinavi (Mishkoh Al-Noor). The twenty-first year. Number 57. Spring and summer. 107-123. [in Persian]
Karimi, Jamshid; Badini, Hassan; Abbaslu, Bakhtiar. (2023). "Distributive justice in Iranian civil rights". The approach of the Islamic revolution. 17th year, No. 62. Spring. 27-46. [in Persian]
Michelot, Agnès (2012), "Egalité des sexes, autonomisation des femmes", Revue Juridique de l'environnement, Volume 37, PP 631-632.
Mirhosseini, Mahsa (2016). "Social justice, indicators and tools for its realization from Imam Khomeini's point of view". Imam Khomeini's portal. 04/09/2016. http://www.imam-khomeini.ir/fa/ n126684C. [in Persian]
Moghadam, Rizvan. (2024). "Inequality in health and women". Salamat newspaper. July 9, 1403. https://vista.ir/m/a/icl3k. [in Persian]
Momenifar, Mehdi. Vazirinejad, Reza; Ahmadinia, Hassan; Rezaian, Mohsen. (2022). "Investigating the mortality trend of children under 5 years old and the economic and health status of their families during the years 2019-2020 in Rafsanjan city: a descriptive study". Journal of Rafsanjan University of Medical Sciences. Volume 22. Number 4. 401-418. [in Persian]
Nabipour, Iraj. (2013). "Analysis of macro-trend health policies of the Islamic Republic of Iran". Southern medicine. 17th year Number 5. 1007-1030. [in Persian]
Rawls, J. (1971), A Theory of Justice, Cambridge, Massachusetts: Belknap Press of
Salari, Ali. (2018). "Equality and non-discrimination in human rights system". Legal research. Volume 17. Number 35. November. 145-169. [in Persian]
Salvati, Abdullah; Shayan Far, Shahnaz. (2017). "Sadrai model in interpreting the principle of equality in human rights". Hikmat Sadraei bimonthly scientific journal, 6th year. Number 2. Spring and summer. 107-120. [in Persian]
Taheri, Seyyed Mehdi. (2008). "Justice from the perspective of martyr Motahari". Pagah Hoza. Number 253. [in Persian]
Theories of Justice, http://jafarhashemlou.blogfa.com/post/2333. [in Persian]
Vaezi, Ahmed. (1400). "Social justice and its relationship with distributive justice". Scientific research quarterly of political science. Twenty-fourth year. Number 95. Autumn. 24-7. [in Persian]
Vahadaniya, Walialah; Seyed Mousavi, Mirsjad, Vahdaninia, Mohammad Amin; Vathouqi Moghadam, Abbas () "Health as a human right, a legal narrative of the logic of governance for health", Ethics and medical history, 2019: pp. 1-18. [in Persian]
Vahdaninia, V. (2010). "Health Paradigm in the Public Policy System: Finding the Right Conceptual Framework for Action?" MSc Thesis [dissertation]. Tehran, Tehran University. [in Persian]
Whitehead M. (1992), "Concepts and Principles of Equity and Health", International Journal of Health Services, 1992; 22(3): 429-445.
Zahedi Asl, Mohammad; Darvishifard, Ali Asghar. (2015). "Social factors affecting the level of social health of the elderly (case study: the elderly of Kohdasht city)". Welfare and Social Development Planning Quarterly. seventh year Number 26. Spring. 1-24. [in Persian]